Reflections & analysis about innovation, technology, startups, investing, healthcare, and more .... with a focus on Minnesota, Land of 10,000 Lakes. Blogging continuously since 2005.

Tag: CNet

‘Conversational Marketing’ – Much Ado About Nothing?

Well, take that Federated Media and your fancy-schmancy new buzz words. Or so Elinor Mills seems to be saying in this piece on CNet today: Want to ‘converse’ with advertisers? Me neither. Federatedmediaconf It’s her review of FM’s glitterati CM Summit yesterday — at SF’s Presidio of all places. All the kool kids were there.

But Elinor rips into the whole concept anyway, bursting the bubble pretty well. Brands are conversations? Hooey, she says:

Hold on. Who asked marketers to join readers online? I know blog publishers need to make money, and they do earn revenue off regular old text, video and banner ads. But I’m suspicious when the “conversation” is initiated by the marketer and not the consumer. And what’s this with the slogan of the conference–“Brands are conversations”? No, they aren’t.

And she wraps up her review, after giving us a few quotes from attendees and speakers, with this gem:

Just as advertisers have been able to get their ads printed on stickers on supermarket fruit, tattooed onto people’s skin and even written in the sky, they will surely blanket the online world in ways we can not even imagine. But let’s not confuse plain old advertising and gimmick marketing with a new form of commercial digital communication that ostensibly gives consumers more control.

I think Elinor ate her Wheaties yesterday. [And, no, General Mills did not pay me to say that…… 🙂 ]

Execs Going Down from Options Backdating

Holy crap! Another CEO just resigned due to probes about options backdating. Here’s how the Wall Steet Journal reported it in an alert moments ago:

“CNET said Chairman and CEO Shelby Bonnie has resigned after a probe found ‘deficiencies’ in the company’s options grants. CNET’s general counsel and head of human resources also resigned. ‘I apologize for the option-related problems that happened under my leadership,’ said Mr. Bonnie, who co-founded the online media company in 1993.” Read more here (behind the paywall).

Wow, this is right on top of the CEO resigning at McAfee, and several other exec departures at other firms. Who’s next, Steve Jobs?

Other concerns have now been raised about Apple as well, as detailed in another story in today’s WSJ: Apple’s Options Probe Could Raise Conflicts.

Speaking of Bono…Sighting at Demo?

Forgot to tell you about one of the funnest things that happened at DEMOfall in San Diego. There was a definite buzz caused by the appearance of a certain face on the floor of the demo pavilion. Read CNet’s take here.

Bono2jpg It was a brilliant PR trick. Who couldn’t believe that Bono, known to be a real tech guy (and even a VC in his own right), might not show up at an event like this? And the guy looked exactly like him. He actually fooled a couple of CNet reporters. I had to tell them when we sat back down in the ballroom for the next session that I knew better: a firm I knew, Mindtouch, had hired an amazing Bono lookalike to hang out in its booth. What a stroke! VP Aaron Fulkerson, whom I know because he’s based in St. Paul, had previously told me the guy would show up. I asked him how he’d found him — hired him through a talent agency? “Nah,” he said, “I found him on the web.” And he said the guy actually knew Bono and had the same (real) first name: Paul.

The best PR stunt I saw at Demo!

Tags: , ,

Final Thoughts on DEMOfall…

Well, two days since my return from San Diego, let me summarize my take on the latest DEMO event and share some random images and opinions. First of all, everything was extremely well run. This is *the* most crack conference team on the planet — logistics, food, press support, absolutely flawless wi-fi, the whole nine yards — even great bumper music. Demofallstagecolors_1 I just wish theyda told me the hotel had two towers, and that if you were unlucky enough to make your reservations a bit too late, you’d get stuck in the West Tower and have to hoof it three-quarters of a mile to where the event was held, in and around the East Tower. For the prices, there has to be a better venue in the San Diego area.

But, more importantly, what was the tenor of the event, and what were the takeaways? I touched on a lot of that in my report published on event-review site Conferenza.com the other day. But let me ramble on a bit more, now that I’m two days removed from it all. DEMOfall was definitely an upbeat affair — exhuberance was in the air at every turn. [Even if sunshine wasn’t. Now, if someone could demo a technology that would remove fog, haze, and overcast from the San Diego climate, that would really be something!] Demofallpavilionscene It was reminiscent of the pre-crash conference scene for sure — and I wondered how many of these people were experiencing this “high” for the first time. My guess would be a large percentage, because there were many, many young faces in the crowd.

The mix of technologies — consumer tech vs. enterprise IT, business vs. home, widgets vs. software (including another kind of widget!) — was excellent. There was something here for everybody. Almost too much — but that’s always the case at DEMO. Trying to cover it all is essentially impossible for any one reporter. Which is why outfits like Ziff Davis/CNet send multiple people — but they have separate media entities, too, which is how they can do that. Demofallpavilionside_1 The press policy is a very democratic one, I learned: it allows only one reporter from any one media outlet, even including the WSJ, NY Times, USA Today. But let me apologize now for not covering all 67 presenting companies. Nothing against any of you that I didn’t — just not enough time. It’s flatly impossible to do, with any depth, anyway. [I did manage to blog some 37 of them, though!]

Would I recommend DEMO as the launchpad for a new startup? Absolutely, positively — if you can handle the rigor and the preparation. It’ll make a better company out of any fledgling startup, I assure you — just going through the process (starting with getting accepted). The next event, which will be #25, is in Palm Desert, CA, January 30 – February 1 (where the weather is guaranteed to be much better). It’s at the Desert Springs Resort & Spa. How does one apply to present? Read all about that here.

Let me share a few more pix I shot at DEMOfall — these with my new little HP Photosmart M425. That’s the one with the new “pretexting” feature… 🙂 Five megapixels, very compact, 3x optical — not bad for a hundred bucks. [More proof of The Cheap Revolution, as Rich Karlgaard calls it.] I’ve included a shot from the demo of the wi-fi bunny, from Paris-based Violet, a product Ed Baig of USA Today called “easily the silliest Demo product.” Demofallwifirabbit Another of my shots shows the two presenters from Eluma on stage, including VP marketing Joe Lichtenberg on the right, who just told me his firm got one of the coveted “Demo God” awards that were handed out at the final evening’s dinner (which I had to miss). Demofalleluma That’s two Demo conferences in a row where companies I’ve run into early and blogged about became Demo God winners. [Just lucky, I guess…]

A funny scene near the end of Wednesday’s closing session was Chris Shipley strutting out with the surfboard giveaway, replete with shades, to the sounds of The Beach Boys’ “Surfin’ USA.” Demofallchrissurfboard I was so hoping to win that nice stick (donated by sponsor Qualcomm). But, alas, the guy in front of me did — and he didn’t even seem excited about it. Dude?

One final ranting bitch about the show, which I just have to get in, is exemplified by my final photo, which is of the CEO of Moixa Energy presenting. [You’ll remember this outfit, if you’ve been reading my blog, as the one that got my vote for the worst name — though I’ve since decided it’s a tie with PrefPass.] His “USB Cell” may be cool — though it certainly isn’t the most visually elegant product I’ve ever seen. Demofallmoixa But could the guy conjur up something better to wear than the most god-awful pair of jeans I’ve even seen? I look better than that when I’ve done lumberjack work for three hours in the woods behind my house, for kee-rist sakes. In his defense, he was just one of several presenters who were dressed shabbily. And, sorry, anything including jeans fits that category for me. Please, Chris, can we have a dress code for presenters? It’s the least they can do for us. Hey, if Steve Jobs is coming on stage — fine, he wears what he wants. But these guys, they ain’t no Steve Jobs — okay? 🙂 Certainly not yet… And having them pretend like they are is just too hard to stomach.

What were the takeaways of DEMOfall 2006?
• The tech economy is strong. But we’re not in a bubble, according to the show’s producers. [How could we be when the Nasdaq is still 55% down from its high in the year 2000?]
• Money is flowing. Many of these startups-you’ve-never-heard-of have already raised substantial funding, as reported in their profiles. And a person can only wonder how so many of them get such amounts, based on what appears to be a sketchy or risky plan. I can only recall a few presenters who said they were bootstrapped — that is, surviving just on their own funds at this point. Whatever happened to the raw, truly undiscovered startups getting a chance? Must they all be VC-backed already?
• Consumer tech continues to influence enterprise IT. And Web 2.0 type services are leading the way here. The center of gravity is now on the consumer or individual user side of things. Internet apps are where the most energy is these days, not in computers, operating systems, desktop apps, and the corporate IT power base of old.
• The tech economy, and really the entire economy, is going global faster than you think. This Demo had the largest number ever of non-U.S. presenting firms. And who knows what percentage of all the firms that pitched are relying at least partially on offshore technology expertise to develop their products. Either that or on immigrants who now call the U.S. home.

One final thing: links to a couple of excellent recaps of the event by some of the good press people covering it. First, a story from CNet with several contributors, including Rafe Needleman, Daniel Terdiman, and Dan Farber, all of whom I chatted with at the conference. And another good story is from Thursday’s edition of USA Today, by Ed Baig.

Tags: